Being in charge of the Thanksgiving turkey means facing a lot of pressure to get it right. To avoid the dreaded complaint that the turkey is dry, I’ve tried it all: brining, basting, covering it with foil, and filling the cavity with onions and herbs instead of stuffing the turkey. These tips were all fine—not great.
One year, I discovered the fix right in my crisper drawer. I was out of onions and garlic, so I quartered as many oranges and lemons as I could and popped them into the turkey with a fistful of herbs. During the long cook time, I crossed my fingers that the turkey would turn out moist and wouldn’t taste like the lemon meringue pie I made the night before.
It worked! The turkey was plenty juicy and tender but not overtly citrusy.
Credit: Simply Recipes / Getty Images
Why I Stuff My Turkey With Citrus
Citrus has a high water content, much like the onions, carrots, and celery many folks use to fill a turkey cavity. As the turkey roasts, the fruit releases moisture and adds subtle citrusy notes that flavor the bird from the inside out.
I recommend sticking with lemons and oranges for the best flavor combination. They work well with the turkey’s mild flavor and complement classic Thanksgiving herbs like sage, rosemary, and thyme. You can use one or a mix of both, but save other citrus fruits, like grapefruit and limes, for a different recipe.
How To Stuff a Turkey With Oranges and Lemons
For a typical 15-pound turkey, I use about four oranges, or a combination of oranges and lemons. Cut the oranges in quarters and the lemons in half, then loosely fill the cavity. You’ll want to fill the space, but don’t try to pack the fruit in tightly or force any extra inside. I also like to add some herbs for an extra layer of flavor. Since no one will see them, I usually use the last clippings of sage, rosemary, and thyme from my garden.
Once the turkey is stuffed, cook it according to your favorite turkey recipe. Filling the cavity can affect cooking time, so check the bird for doneness with a meat thermometer. Insert it into the thickest part of the breast and the innermost parts of the thigh and wing, making sure it doesn’t touch bone. The thermometer should register at least 165°F in all three places.
How Does Citrus Affect the Gravy?
There’s one last benefit to this turkey stuffing method: better gravy. The best gravy is made from scratch using the drippings from the pan, and it only gets tastier when the turkey is filled with flavorful components.
If you’re worried about the gravy tasting like orange sauce, you can always dilute the drippings with unsalted turkey or chicken stock until the flavors are balanced. But I don’t usually find this necessary. That little bit of acidity from the oranges and lemons is a great way to cut through the gravy’s richness and brighten up the whole Thanksgiving plate. After all, the gravy goes on everything!
Read the original article on Simply Recipes