Reviewed by Dietitian Casey Wing, RD, CD
Credit: Getty Images. EatingWell Design.
Key Points
-
Apple cider has slightly more fiber than apple juice, but not enough to impact blood sugar significantly.
-
Both apple cider and apple juice are high in sugar and can cause quick blood sugar spikes.
-
Pairing apple cider or juice with protein, fat or fiber can help reduce blood sugar spikes.
When temperatures dip at the first sign of fall, there’s nothing better than sipping on a warm cup of fresh apple cider to ring in the season. This autumnal treat is anticipated by many, but you may be wondering what sets it apart from traditional apple juice.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Jill McNutt, M.S., RD, advises, “Apple juice and apple cider both start with whole apples that are crushed and pressed to extract their juice. The main difference is how they’re processed.” Tara Durden, M.S., RDN, adds that “apple juice is filtered and pasteurized, which makes it transparent, sweeter and typically shelf-stable.” This filtration removes some of the pulp and fiber, which is why this liquid is less opaque. But, is one better for blood sugar than the other? We asked dietitians how apple cider and apple juice compare, and what makes each beverage unique in a blood sugar–conscious way. Here’s what they said.
How Apple Cider Affects Blood Sugar
Apple cider is generally unfiltered, leaving some of the natural pulp and sediment that gives it a cloudy appearance and slightly tart flavor. This pulp can give apple cider a bit more fiber than apple juice. In general, consuming foods and beverages with fiber can help to blunt glucose spikes. Fiber slows glucose absorption, allowing the sugar to enter the bloodstream more gradually. However, because the fiber content in apple cider is so minimal, it does not positively benefit blood sugar as you might expect.
McNutt notes, “One cup of apple cider provides about 24 grams of naturally occurring sugars. Since it has very little fiber, protein or fat to slow digestion, that sugar gets absorbed quickly and can cause a rapid rise in blood sugar.”
How Apple Juice Affects Blood Sugar
Similar to apple cider, apple juice contains naturally occurring sugars, with very little fiber. Without another source of fiber, protein or fat, these carbohydrates are absorbed relatively quickly and can raise blood sugar levels.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Karen Louise Scheuner, M.A., RDN, notes, “While apple juice also contains small amounts of potassium and other nutrients, these do not significantly change its impact on blood sugar.”
Apple Cider vs. Apple Juice: Which Is Better for Blood Sugar?
So when it comes to blood sugar response, is there one clear winner? “Although apple cider may retain slightly more nutrients compared to filtered apple juice, including small amounts of potassium, vitamin C and antioxidant compounds such as polyphenols, these nutrients do not significantly offset its immediate impact on blood sugar,” says Scheuner.
McNutt adds, “It’s easy to assume apple cider would be better for blood sugar since it retains some of the natural apple pulp. However, the actual fiber content remains minimal in both beverages. One cup of apple juice provides about 0.5 grams of fiber, while apple cider provides less than 1 gram per cup.” While apple cider may contain slightly more fiber, the difference is too small to have a meaningful impact on blood sugar. Both beverages raise blood sugar because they provide a concentrated source of sugar with very little fiber to slow digestion.
Other Tips for Better Blood Sugar
Choosing the right beverage is a good first step, but it is only one piece of the picture. How your body handles glucose depends just as much on everyday habits, including when and how you eat and how often you move. The good news is that these changes don’t require a complicated plan or a major lifestyle overhaul. Small, consistent choices add up over time and can help you avoid sharp spikes and crashes. Here is what registered dietitians recommend:
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Get moving. Scheuner says, “A 10- to 15-minute walk after meals can help improve blood sugar regulation. Choose movement you enjoy rather than using exercise to compensate for eating.”
-
Eat consistently. Regular, balanced meals and snacks can help prevent extreme hunger and support steadier blood sugar levels.
-
Choose whole fruit. McNutt advises, “Choose whole fruit over juice or cider. A medium apple provides about 4 grams of fiber, which helps slow digestion and supports a more gradual rise in blood sugar.”
-
Balance your meals. As Durden recommends, “Balance your meals and snacks with a carb and protein or fat. Make sure to avoid solo carbs.”
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Stay hydrated with water. Drinking enough water helps your kidneys flush out excess sugar through urine, and it’s associated with a decreased risk of developing diabetes.
Our Expert Take
While apple cider and apple juice differ slightly nutritionally, with apple cider containing more pulp and fiber than apple juice, both beverages elicit a blood sugar response. Because both drinks are high in sugar with little to no fiber or protein, the high carbohydrate content gets absorbed into the bloodstream quickly, which can lead to increased blood glucose. However, this is not a reason to avoid these beverages altogether. If you want to enjoy apple juice or apple cider, pairing your drink with a high-fiber or high -protein snack will help to reduce blood glucose spikes.
Add EatingWell as a preferred source on Google to see more of our stories on Google news and search results.
Read the original article on EatingWell