Skip to content
Menu
bubbleandsqueakkids.com
bubbleandsqueakkids.com
Never Use Pre-Shredded Cheese for This One Dish
November 20, 2026

Never Use Pre-Shredded Cheese for This One Dish

When I make mac and cheese from scratch, I want a creamy (not clumpy) sauce that coats every noodle. But even when I follow the recipe, the sauce sometimes turns grainy or clumpy. The type of cheese and how you add it play a big role in how the finished sauce turns out. The good news is that a simple swap at the grocery store can lead to a smooth, creamy sauce.

​Why Skip Pre-Shredded Cheese?

I spent most of my life avoiding pre-shredded cheese until J. Kenji López-Alt, surprisingly, convinced me it has its place. I get the appeal of the bag. On a busy night, pre-shredded cheese feels like one less thing to deal with. But mac and cheese is not the right place for this shortcut.

​Pre-shredded cheeses often contain anti-caking agents, such as potato starch or powdered cellulose, that keep the shreds from clumping in the bag. They’re helpful in the bag, but the coatings can prevent the shreds from melting smoothly. For mac and cheese, that can mean a grainy or pasty sauce.

​Not every bag will make the sauce grainy (formulations vary), but grating your own cheese removes a major variable. And for a dish like mac and cheese, where the cheese sauce is the main event, grating from a block is worth the effort.

Credit: Simply Recipes / Getty Images

Choose a Good Melting Cheese

Start with a good old block of supermarket cheddar. Mild and sharp cheddar melt more smoothly than extra-sharp or very aged cheddar. If you like a more pronounced flavor, sharp cheddar is still great and works especially well combined with a good melting cheese, like Monterey Jack. For a splurge, you can even take chef Cal Hingston’s approach and use a mix of fontina, Gouda, and aged cheddar.

How I Keep the Sauce Smooth

I grate the cheese before I start the sauce so it’s ready when I need it. Then I make my usual roux, whisk in the milk, and cook the sauce until it thickens. I take the pan off the heat and stir in the cheese a small handful at a time, letting each addition melt before adding the next. If it needs a bit of help, briefly return the pan to the burner on very low heat. Don’t boil the finished sauce or turn up the heat to force shreds to melt, since that can cause the sauce to separate.

Pre-shredded cheese has its place, but for the creamiest, dreamiest mac and cheese, grating it yourself is the way to go. And I think in this case, López-Alt would agree!

Read the original article on Simply Recipes

Recent Posts

  • The Frozen Vegetable Chefs Say Is Better Than Fresh
  • The Costco Frozen Cinnamon Rolls So Good, I Stopped Making Them From Scratch
  • 5 Easy Dinners To Make the Week Before Thanksgiving
  • 2 Recalls You Need To Know About This Week
  • I Thought Thanksgiving Turkey Was Blah—Until I Started Doing This

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026

Categories

  • Article
©2026 bubbleandsqueakkids.com | Powered by WordPress and Superb Themes!