Here’s the thing about roasting a whole turkey: Its large, rounded shape, which makes it a gorgeous holiday centerpiece, also makes it difficult to achieve even browning. Getting the sides of a turkey as well-cooked and chestnut brown as the top isn’t made any easier with a high-sided roasting pan, which is why I stopped using one for my roast turkey.
People understandably associate a traditional roasting pan with anything roasted. But after cooking professionally in restaurants and home kitchens for many years, I can tell you with certainty there’s a better option. Once I started roasting my turkeys on a rimmed baking sheet, I never looked back, and my turkeys have never looked better.
Use a Baking Sheet Instead of a Roasting Pan
The same durable baking sheets you use for sheet pan dinners are my top choice for roasting a turkey because the short sides don’t trap steam as it cooks. Without a barrier, moisture can evaporate, and more direct heat will circulate around the turkey, including the undersides of the legs—a notoriously tricky spot to crisp.
Even when fitted with a rack to lift the turkey up, a turkey still sits low in a traditional roasting pan, with the bottom third blocked by the pan’s sides. Roasting pans also have thick bottoms and sides, which make them sturdy (a good thing), but it also holds all that heat in, making it difficult for the skin near the pan’s edges to brown. Disposable aluminum pans are often even deeper than a roasting pan, and their flimsy construction feels like an accident waiting to happen.
Credit: Simply Recipes / Amazon
How To Roast a Turkey on a Baking Sheet
Fit a large, rimmed baking sheet with a rack and set the turkey on top so it sits just above the rim of the pan. Don’t forget to adjust your oven racks so there is enough room for this tall bird! Because the pan is shallow, you won’t be able to add much liquid or vegetables to the bottom, yielding fewer drippings for gravy. But that’s just another reason to advocate for time-saving make-ahead turkey gravy; whisk the drippings you do have into the gravy when reheating to boost the flavor.
I love that using a baking sheet doesn’t restrict how you prepare your turkey. You can dry brine or wet brine your turkey, stuff it, or keep it simple and rub a flavored butter under the skin. I’ve even fit a spatchcocked turkey on a baking sheet, though admittedly, it was a smaller 12 to-13 pound bird.
Before grabbing a baking sheet and heating up the oven, remember that a turkey is heavy and a baking sheet doesn’t have handles. Be very cautious when transferring it to the oven so the bird doesn’t slip right onto the kitchen floor. I implore you to not try this with a warped baking sheet, or one prone to buckling. There will still be rendered fat and turkey juices coming off the bird, and having those spill will create a mess you don’t want on Thanksgiving.
Read the original article on Simply Recipes