Skip to content
Menu
bubbleandsqueakkids.com
bubbleandsqueakkids.com
I Stopped Making Pumpkin Pie—I Bake This Retro Recipe Instead (It’s So Easy)
November 14, 2026

I Stopped Making Pumpkin Pie—I Bake This Retro Recipe Instead (It’s So Easy)

Pumpkin pie is great, but 75 percent of the time the bottom crust is basically raw. Dessert plates come back with the crust mostly intact and the filling dug out like it was strip-mined.

Sure, you can par-bake the crust first, but who has time for that in the midst of make-ahead gravy and peeling a giant bag of potatoes? Inspired by my mom, I made a switch to an alternative that’s way simpler, and just as lovable.

The “Impossible” Alternative to Pumpkin Pie

A lifelong clipper of recipes, my mom has an old recipe from a Bisquick box squirreled away: Impossible Pumpkin Pie. It’s part of Bisquick’s family of “impossible” pies where a little Bisquick mixed into the filling makes a crustless pie that’s just firm enough to keep its shape when sliced.

The lack of the doughy crust issue is where Impossible Pumpkin Pie shines. It’s a one-bowl marvel that’s so easy to throw together, with the same ingredients you know and love from traditional pumpkin pie: canned pumpkin puree, evaporated milk, eggs, sugar, pumpkin spice. It’s got the creaminess and familiarity of the real deal without the hassle.

The Betty Crocker website has a recipe—now called “Impossibly Easy Pumpkin Pie”—but it differs some from the one my mom uses (I think hers is from the 1980s). I use a mashup of the two, so it’s helpful to have some tips.

Credit: Simply Recipes / Sara Bir

Tips for Impossible Pie

  • The original recipe calls for 3/4 cup of sugar. I found that the current amount of 1/2 cup makes a plenty sweet pie, but my mom prefers 3/4 cup.

  • For a richer taste, use brown sugar instead of white sugar.

  • The current recipe calls for one tablespoon of butter. Come on, let’s live a little! Go with the two tablespoons called for in the original.

  • The recipe says to basically dump everything together and stir until blended. However, the tablespoon (or two) of softened butter won’t easily assimilate into the other ingredients. I recommend melting and cooling the butter a bit first.

  • The updated recipe has 1 1/2 teaspoons of pumpkin pie spice; the original, 2 1/2 teaspoons. I walked the line and upped it to two teaspoons, which I think is just right.

  • The recipe online says to chill the pie for three hours before eating, as well as to refrigerate leftovers. I’ve tried it chilled and at room temperature, and I think this pie’s texture and flavor is better when it’s chilled.

  • Without the textural contrast between crisp crust and creamy filling, impossible pumpkin pie benefits from an accompaniment. I like a dab of whipped cream for lightness.

  • Bisquick recently reformulated its recipe. I noticed that the new Bisquick left tiny pockets of dry ingredients in the batter, which baked into firm little micro-nuggets that were a little distracting. Otherwise, new Bisquick works just fine.

Read the original article on Simply Recipes

Recent Posts

  • I Could Eat This 20-Minute Lunch Every Day (And Sometimes I Do)
  • The $1.25 Find That Makes Cleaning My Grimy Toaster Oven So Much Easier
  • 19 One-Pot Mediterranean Diet Dinners for Fall
  • Green Bean Casserole vs. Sweet Potato Casserole: Which Is Better for Blood Sugar?
  • The #1 Food for Gut Health Isn’t a Fruit or Vegetable—It’s This

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026

Categories

  • Article
©2026 bubbleandsqueakkids.com | Powered by WordPress and Superb Themes!