All you need to make pumpkin pie is pureed pumpkin, eggs, evaporated milk, a blend of sugar and spices, and a pie crust. I love that all of the ingredients can be dumped in a bowl, whisked together, and poured into the crust. It’s so easy. Where does making the perfect pumpkin pie get tricky? It’s all in the baking.
Pumpkin pies are custard based. The filling has eggs and dairy, which thickens as it bakes into a delicate texture. It relies on an ideal baking time and temperature. You don’t want to underbake your pie, but it’s also crucial not to leave the pie in the oven for too long. This will completely ruin its texture.
Don’t Overbake Your Pumpkin Pie
Overbaking is easily the most common pumpkin pie mistake. This often happens when a pumpkin pie is left in the oven until the center is completely firm. When a pumpkin pie is overbaked, it cracks across the surface, eliminating that beautiful sheer appearance.
Each bite is dry and grainy. To avoid this, the goal is to pull the pumpkin pie from the oven before it has fully set, allowing residual heat to do the rest of the work.
Credit: Simply Recipes / Getty Images
How To Tell When Pumpkin Pie is Done
Most pumpkin pie recipes have a bake time of 50 minutes to one hour, or even longer. It takes quite a while! That’s because the eggs need to slowly reach a certain temperature to set up properly. The key is to find a balance between overbaking and underbaking.
Visual cues will give you helpful insight as to whether your pie is done, and checking your pie about five minutes before the final bake time will help to achieve this. Here are two fool-proof ways to check:
The jiggle test: The edges of your pie should be set with a domed or puffed appearance, with a slight jiggle in the center. Gently tap a wooden spoon against the pie dish. If it ripples across the surface, your pie needs more time. If only the center moves with just a light jiggle, it’s time to remove it from the oven. Then, leave it to rest so that carryover cooking kicks in. The pie is holding on to plenty of residual heat, and that heat will finish baking the center.
Use a thermometer: To be extra sure your pie is done, you can insert a probe thermometer into the center. It should read 170°F to 175°F.
Read the original article on Simply Recipes